Mixed Reactions to First Trailer of James Gunn’s Superman: Krypto vs. Lois Lane’s Fanbase

James Gunn has finally given fans a sneak peek at his upcoming Superman movie with a generous teaser trailer. As you’d expect, it’s sparked a lot of discussion online with opinions varying from excitement to skepticism. Here’s the lowdown on what people are saying.

From where I stand, the trailer strikes a classic and uplifting tone, a fresh breeze in the current climate. Intriguingly, it keeps its cards close to the chest, revealing very little about the plot or character dynamics. But stay tuned; we anticipate that future trailers will take a more daring approach, showing us what’s to love about this new take on Superman. Right now, this optimistic, vibe-focused preview is precisely what fans have been longing for, especially since it contrasts sharply with the considerably grimmer DCEU’s vision for Superman.

Starting with the positive reactions, it’s no surprise that many are praising this first look. Gunn has built a strong rapport with audiences over the past decade with hits like Guardians of the Galaxy, The Suicide Squad, and Peacemaker. Even with darker themes, Gunn keeps hope at the forefront, a balance he seems to maintain in this Superman reboot. It looks like he’s doubling down on his signature hopeful narrative style, a refreshing approach after his edgier projects at DC.

Fans are vocal on social media. ClarkQuill97 celebrated, tweeting, “This is straight up a comicbook come to life. Superman nation, we won.” With a username like that, you know they’ve been itching for this kind of Superman portrayal, and it seems like this trailer met their high expectations.

Rachel Brosnahan’s portrayal of Lois Lane is also winning hearts, even at this early stage. People are already expressing enthusiasm online about her take on the iconic character.

Massive comic book fan account, PridefulSin, cherishes the movie’s focus on Superman as a savior and inspirer rather than a brooding figure. Winning over such influential voices with just a teaser is a victory in itself.

Illustrator Dan Veesenmeyer predicts, “Krypto is gonna put asses in seats.” Let’s face it, everyone loves a super dog, and Krypto with a cape is an easy sell. Gaming personality Ultima chimed in, saying, “I have got the biggest smile on my face right now.” A super-powered canine is a fun way to introduce a new superhero era!

The cinematic looks on the brighter side for many, with fans pleased to see Superman portrayed as the classic boy scout once again, rather than the moody alien approach. Some folks, myself included, appreciated Zack Snyder’s unique vision, but starting with a more traditional Superman might be the way to go. Out of Context Simpsons Couch Gags even stepped in to comment.

However, not everyone is thrilled about the more light-hearted treatment. Some pointed out that certain scenes seemed a bit too ‘made for TV.’ It’s worth noting that the film is still in the early stages of post-production. ComicAccuracy remarked that while it doesn’t look like a “fake movie,” it still falls short of their expectations.

BroBible’s Eric Italiano shared his thoughts, finding the tone appealing but expressing concerns about the aesthetic with some diplomacy: “The action looks good, but everything else looks… cheap? Maybe it’s a sign of the times, but the cinematic gloss of this trailer feels far less than that of ‘Man of Steel.'”

Not everyone held back. One Twitter user critiqued the trailer harshly, suggesting it seemed targeted at a much younger audience and criticizing the acting and visuals.

The divided reactions aren’t entirely unexpected. Some audiences embrace the new direction, while others hold onto the darker ‘SnyderVerse’ style or prefer a more mature take on Superman. The great thing about comic book characters, especially icons like Superman, is that they can be interpreted in countless ways. Gunn’s rendition harkens back to the Silver Age, but if the DCU takes off, there’s plenty of room for growth and evolution.

No matter where you land on the trailer, one thing seems clear: Krypto might just steal the show and drive ticket sales. Here’s hoping he stays safe from nefarious foes like Lex Luthor! We’ll have to wait and see how everything pans out when the film hits theaters on July 11, 2025.