PB Tails Metal Crush TMR Review: Fallout-Inspired Controller Featuring TMR Sticks

The PB Tails Metal Crush Defender TMR controller is a head-turner with its audacious design and feel that justifies its premium price tag. Equipped with TMR technology, it delivers exceptionally smooth stick movements. Although it misses some features expected in this price range, it remains an elegant choice for controller enthusiasts and a delightful experience overall.

PB Tails, though a niche player in the gaming world, specializes in crafting unusual and quirky controllers. They often employ unique materials, such as aluminum alloy, and are inspired by unexpected sources like automobiles, exemplified by their pixelated CHOC controller. Intrigued by their designs, I was initially doubtful about their everyday functionality. However, the PB Tails Crush range caught my eye thanks to their TMR sticks, a cutting-edge advancement that’s a step above Hall Effect sticks and only embraced by a handful of brands so far. I was eager to try it out, and I’m pleased to share how this peculiar-looking controller wowed me. It manages to appear tough yet feels premium—a quality many third-party controllers lack compared to offerings from Xbox and PlayStation.

Why You Should Trust Me

My name is Jennifer Young, and I’ve been a gaming contributor at Windows Central for two years. I’ve been gaming since the 90s, equally at home in the realms of Dark Souls, Diablo, and even Petz 4. While I play mainly on Steam Deck, Xbox, and PC, my real collector’s passion lies with controllers—not shoes or handbags. Only a select few make it into my daily lineup, and I’m always happy to tell you which ones and why through my detailed reviews here.

Review Sample Disclosure

This review was made possible by a review unit provided by PB Tails. They had no input on the review content before publication.

PB Tails Metal Crush Controller Review: Pricing and Specifications

The Metal Crush Defender TMR controller is priced at $109.99. While there are plastic alternatives available starting at $45.99, those who are drawn to the TMR sticks should consider the luxury version.

Metal Crush Defender Controller Specs

• Price: $109.99 through PB Tails
• Connectivity: USB-A to USB-C cable, Bluetooth, or a 2.4GHz wireless dongle
• Compatibility: Windows PC, SteamOS, Android, Apple, Nintendo Switch
• Additional Controls: 6-axis gyro sensor
• Features: Anti-drift TMR joysticks, Hall Effect triggers, interchangeable joystick caps, magnetic case, customizable RGB lighting
• Battery Life: 10 hours
• Dimensions: 155 mm x 101 mm x 66 mm (6.1 x 4 x 2.6 inches)
• Weight: 346 grams (0.76 lbs)

The price of the Crush range varies with the shell design. For example, the plastic ‘China White’ Crush TMR is $64.99, and other options like the Porsche-inspired Crush 550 TMR retail for $79.99. The Ghost Silver variant costs $99.99.

I’ve tested the Metal Crush Defender TMR, precisely priced at $109.99, and designed with a metallic yellow worn finish that echoes Fallout’s post-apocalyptic vibe. These controllers are mostly available through PB Tails’ official site, with some models also found on AliExpress.

Inside the box, you’ll find a stylish leather-effect case, complete with cushioned lining, a slot for the 2.4GHz dongle, and a net pouch for the charging and wired-use USB cable.

PB Tails Metal Crush Controller Review: The Good

The TMR sticks on this controller are incredibly smooth, showcasing a marked improvement over Hall Effect sticks that exceeded my expectations. It’s a well-crafted piece that exudes luxury. Setting it up wirelessly via the USB receiver is a breeze, and it seamlessly supports Bluetooth, offering easy toggling between modes.

From an aesthetic standpoint, this controller is simply stunning. It looks as though it could have been assembled from a Fallout scrapyard, with a yellow metal exterior and mirrored sticks adding to its scrapyard chic. Detailed craftsmanship is visible down to the wear marks and meticulous patterns etched around the joysticks. Despite its rugged look, it feels surprisingly opulent in hand, akin to the Xbox Elite Series 2 controller—a testament to its quality.

Priced at $109.99, this controller offers a unique luxury experience. The accompanying leatherette carrying case enhances the opulence. The Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR) technology incorporated in the sticks wasn’t only a visual novelty but quickly proved its worth through performance.

What is Tunneling Magnetoresistance (TMR)?

Your curiosity about TMR might mirror my own initial confusion, "I just got used to Hall Effect—what’s TMR all about?" Well, let me enlighten you.

Most current controllers use analog potentiometer joysticks that rely on physical contact for measuring movement. Over time, wear and tear lead to the notorious stick drift. Hall Effect sensors, however, employ magnets to gauge movements, eliminate direct contact, reduce drift significantly, and improve precision—though major brands like Xbox haven’t yet hopped on this tech bandwagon. That said, many third-party companies have adopted it eagerly, seen in models like the GameSir G7 SE, Turtle Beach Stealth Ultra, and Razer Wolverine V3 Pro.

Taking it further, TMR utilizes magnetic tech but focuses on resistance changes rather than voltage. It’s hailed as more precise, detecting minimal movements and being light on battery usage—albeit with a higher price point, explaining its market scarcity so far.

I initially doubted whether TMR sticks would noticeably surpass the Hall Effect sticks on my GameSir G7 SE, but the Metal Crush controller left me in awe. The sticks glide with a featherlight ease. Although I’m partial to grippy or concave surfaces, the Metal Crush’s sleek, convex sticks were agreeable, though adding texture would improve them—admittedly, a minor quibble.

The triggers and bumpers feel durable and reassuringly solid. Its 10-hour battery life proved true to claims during testing. While it doesn’t reach the Xbox Elite Series 2’s 40-hour peak, 10 hours suffice if you charge periodically.

Connecting the controller across various devices was straightforward, facilitated by the 2.4GHz wireless dongle. I mainly used it with my JSAUX Steam Deck dock and plugged it into my laptop for Xbox cloud gaming. Although it doesn’t officially support Xbox, this workaround made it compatible. I didn’t test it with the Nintendo Switch, but there’s a button to switch seamlessly between Switch and PC modes.

An interesting addition is the Turbo button, allowing rapid-fire assignments to any face button—a handy cheat mode that saves your thumbs from repetitive strain. While some in-game settings offer similar features, having it integrated into the hardware is exceedingly beneficial when options are limited.

PB Tails Metal Crush Controller Review: The Bad

With a smooth, mirrored finish, these joysticks look intriguing but might be problematic for players with sweaty hands.

Given its premium cost, the controller could benefit from features like trigger stops and programmable rear buttons found in rival high-end models.

I’ve touched upon the joystick’s glossy texture—a unique choice that could become problematic for moist fingers during intense sessions. While it didn’t bother me too much, more grip would have improved performance without sacrificing the aesthetic. Since the controller’s design takes cues from cars, textured or engraved metal sticks could strike a balance between functionality and style.

Regarding price, the Metal Crush TMR sits in the luxury tier where additional features are expected. Although the TMR sticks and Hall Effect triggers impress, the absence of FPS-friendly trigger stops and rear remappable buttons—standard in peers at this level—is noteworthy.

Finally, the magnetic faceplate system is ingeniously subtle. I initially missed its detachability due to seamless integration. However, replacement faceplate options are limited—only basic Red, White, and Blue designs are currently available despite promotional images hinting at appealing transparent shells not yet on sale. It’s a missed opportunity to expand this unique feature, and I would certainly purchase a few if given more design options.

PB Tails Metal Crush Controller Review: Alternatives to Consider

If TMR stick technology intrigues you, there are alternatives using less costly materials worth exploring. The GameSir Tarantula Pro stands as a main competitor, featuring TMR sticks and an inventive rotating face button mechanism that adapts when switching between PC and Nintendo Switch—how clever! It’s also more affordable at $69.99, though with a trade-off in premium feel compared to PB Tails.

Another budget-friendly option is the GameSir Cyclone 2 Pro wireless, albeit without extensive customization options.

PB Tails Metal Crush Controller Review: Final Thoughts

This controller stands in its own league with style, though not perfect. While it doesn’t dominate my list of daily-use controllers, it’s a pleasure to own and test. It’s rare to come across a luxury controller on par with the Xbox Elite Series 2 in both style and craftsmanship, but the Metal Crush Defender rises to the occasion. Its daring design, precision-centric sticks, and premium materials should captivate controller collectors eager to try something different. However, it’s not without its setbacks. At this price, adding rear buttons, trigger stops, and texture enhancements would elevate it to perfection. Nonetheless, I’m excited to continue using it with my Steam Deck—it has been quite the rewarding experience.

You Should Buy This If:

• You desire a uniquely designed, premium controller with a striking rugged metal aesthetic.
• You prioritize next-level joystick precision featuring TMR technology.

You Should Not Buy This If:

• You need practical gaming features like trigger stops or remappable buttons, or prefer any customization software.
• You have excessively sweaty hands, as the mirrored and convex joysticks may present challenges.

All things considered, while there are areas for improvement, the PB Tails Metal Crush Defender is a singular delight, offering something distinct from the norm.