Star Rail Raises Questions About the Rumored ‘Starry Sky Valley’

HoYoverse, a dominant force in the gacha game industry, has consistently astonished fans with hits like Genshin Impact and Honkai: Star Rail. These games have set new standards, and if the whispers in the gaming community hold any truth, there’s more magic brewing in the studio. Rumor has it that a new game, Starry Sky Valley, is under development. Although the specifics of its gameplay and storyline remain shrouded in mystery, there’s much speculation about how titles like Honkai: Star Rail might shape this new release.

While each of HoYoverse’s games—Genshin Impact, Zenless Zone Zero, and Honkai: Star Rail—comes with its distinct flair, they all fall under the broader categories of adventure and action gameplay. Genshin Impact and Zenless Zone Zero lean towards a high-paced RTC style, whereas Star Rail offers a turn-based strategy experience. HoYoverse seems to enjoy a pattern in releasing its games. Based on the sequence—Genshin before Star Rail, followed by ZZZ—it appears there’s a deliberate alternating focus. Though Starry Sky Valley’s concept is still under wraps, if it follows a path akin to Star Rail or the routes blazed by Genshin and Zenless Zone Zero, it could have major implications for the studio’s trajectory.

HoYoverse games are cash magnets, consistently raking in substantial revenue every month. Honkai: Star Rail, at times, has even surpassed Genshin Impact in this department. While financial success can fluctuate—like the notable $12 million revenue dip between September and October for Star Rail—the game owes its appeal to its uniqueness as a turn-based gacha title. There aren’t many games like it, and HoYoverse might consider maintaining this uniqueness to steer clear of self-competition.

For HoYoverse, Genshin Impact and Zenless Zone Zero’s competitive landscape might serve as a valuable lesson. Genshin Impact stands as the flagship of the company, maintaining a monthly income between $20 to $30 million. In contrast, Zenless Zone Zero has faced challenges meeting similar expectations, despite its narrower focus. Tailoring Starry Sky Valley in a way that echoes Honkai: Star Rail could stifle its potential and diminish the entertainment value across these games.

Conversely, if Starry Sky Valley chooses an action-oriented gameplay instead, it might struggle to carve out its identity. The niches of Genshin Impact and ZZZ are already well-defined, and unless this upcoming title introduces something novel, it risks blending into the existing lineup rather than standing out.

Interestingly, Starry Sky Valley might veer away from HoYoverse’s traditional offerings. In 2023, rumors started swirling about a cozy simulator project from the developer, poised to rival Animal Crossing. As this genre gains traction, with games like Tales of the Shire leading the charge, exploring it could be a strategic move for HoYoverse. Leaked visuals of Starry Sky Valley depict scenes suggesting a life-simulation setting, featuring movable cameras and avatars engaging in activities like tree-cutting in an open field.

If these leaks are accurate, HoYoverse could sidestep the potential pitfall of diluting the uniqueness offered by games like Honkai: Star Rail or sticking too closely to the Genshin and ZZZ formula. Venturing away from their usual action-packed gameplay could introduce a refreshing change, positioning the developer for an exciting and possibly groundbreaking venture.